Meeting Date: October 5, 2010
Prepared by: Heidi Burch
City Council
Agenda Item Summary
Name: Consideration of a Resolution approving one of the City’s free use days at the Sunset
Center Theater for the 2010 Carmel Authors and Ideas Festival held from September 24-26, 2010.
Description: The organizers of the Carmel Authors and Ideas Festival requested one of the City’s free use days at the Sunset Theater for the 2010 event that ran from September 24-26. Last year, the Council approved use of the theater for the event. This year, the request was inadvertently not placed on a Council agenda in time for the event. Therefore, approval after-the-fact is being requested.
This annual festival brings together a host of world-renowned authors and other luminaries in a small setting, allowing for considerable audience interaction with the various speakers. Attendees come from around the globe to this event, and the positive publicity it generates for the City is significant.
Overall Cost:
City Funds: N/A
Grant Funds: N/A
Staff Recommendation: Adopt the Resolution.
Important Considerations: The City is granted five “free use” days each fiscal year. Upon
approval of this request, the City will have one more “free use” day left for the remainder
of the fiscal year, ending June 30, 2011.
Decision Record: None.
Reviewed by:
_____________________________ __________________
Rich Guillen, City Administrator Date
CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
CITY COUNCIL
RESOLUTION 2010-
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA APPROVING ONE OF THE CITY’S FREE USE DAYS AT THE SUNSET CENTER THEATER FOR THE CARMEL AUTHORS AND IDEAS FESTIVAL, HELD FROM SEPTEMBER 24-26, 2010
WHEREAS, the City has a total of five free use days available each fiscal year for non-profit civic organizations that provide a public service to the Carmel community; and
WHEREAS, the Carmel Authors and Ideas Festival brings world-renowned authors and luminaries to the City of Carmel-by-the-Sea and;
WHEREAS, the event brings many people from around the world into the City to attend the event and casts the City in a favorable light by virtue of its international stature.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED THAT THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA DOES:
1. Approve one of the City’s “free use” days of the Sunset Center Theater for the Carmel Authors and Ideas Festival held from September 24-26, 2010.
PASSED AND ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA this 5th day of October 2010, by the following roll call vote:
AYES: COUNCIL MEMBERS:
NOES: COUNCIL MEMBERS:
ABSENT: COUNCIL MEMBERS:
SIGNED:
_______________________
SUE McCLOUD, MAYOR
ATTEST:
_____________________
Heidi Burch, City Clerk
“of the people, by the people, for the people” of Carmel-by-the-Sea
Friday, October 1, 2010
CITY COUNCIL: Resolution Authorizing Allocation & Expenditure of California Citizens' Option for Public Safety (COPS) Grant Funds
Meeting Date: October 5, 2010
Prepared by: Sgt. Mel Mukai
City Council
Agenda Item Summary
Name: Consideration of a Resolution authorizing the allocation and expenditure of the California Citizens’ Option for Public Safety (COPS) grant funds for Fiscal Year 2011-2012.
Description: State Senate Bill (SB 76) provides the City of Carmel-by-the-Sea a $100,000
allocation in grant funds under a public safety grant known as the California Citizens’
Option for Public Safety (COPS). The total cost for one police officer position, including
salary and benefits, exceeds the grant allocation. Consequently, the officer’s annual
compensation must be funded in part by local funds.
Overall Cost:
FY 11-12
City Funds: $ 8,525 or less
Grant Funds: $ 100,000 (plus interest)
Staff Recommendation:
Staff recommends adoption of the proposed Resolution.
Important Considerations:
Adoption of the proposed Resolution allows the funding of one police officer position that will be assigned to front-line patrol.
Decision Record:
Resolution 2009-61 approved by Council on September 1, 2009, authorizing the FY 2010-11 expenditure for COPS funds for one police officer position.
Reviewed by:
_________________________________ _____________________
Rich Guillen, City Administrator Date
CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
STAFF REPORT
TO: MAYOR MCCLOUD AND COUNCIL MEMBERS
THROUGH: RICH GUILLEN, CITY ADMINISTRATOR
FROM: MEL MUKAI, SERGEANT
MIKE CALHOUN, COMMANDER
GEORGE E. RAWSON, PUBLIC SAFETY DIRECTOR
DATE: SEPTEMBER 21, 2010
SUBJECT: CONSIDERATION OF A RESOLUTION TO ACCEPT THE FISCAL YEAR 2011-12 CALIFORNIA’S CITIZENS’ OPTION FOR PUBLIC SAFETY (COPS) GRANT FUNDS AND APPROVE THE PROPOSED SPENDING PLAN
RECOMMENDED MOTION:
Adopt the Resolution.
BACKGROUND:
The Citizens’ Options for Public Safety (COPS) Program was signed into law by Governor Gray Davis on July 6, 2000. The COPS program established a "Supplemental Law Enforcement Special Fund” (SLESF), which annually allocates entitlement grants to cities and counties to augment public safety. The grant amounts vary, based on population. Historically, smaller communities such as Carmel-by-the-Sea receive a minimum fixed amount of $100,000.
COPS funds cannot be remitted until certain processes are completed, as required by Government Code § 30061 – 30065. These statutes require the Director of Public Safety to propose a spending plan and submit it to City Council for review.
The Council must hold a public hearing, allow for public comment, and adopt the spending plan by Resolution. After City Council ratification, the Resolution is forwarded to the County of Monterey Supplemental Law Enforcement Oversight Committee (SLEOC), which reviews and certifies that the spending plan complies with the above referenced Government code requirements. SLESF funds are restricted to front-line municipal police services and must supplement, not
supplant, current, front-line law enforcement services. Funds must be encumbered or spent within the two-year grant cycle. Any unspent funds must be remanded back to the state via the County Auditor’s office.
It is anticipated the State of California will again approve the Citizens’ Option for Public Safety (COPS) grant funds for FY 11-12. The state legislature has not yet adopted the final budget, but it is probable that the minimum awards for smaller communities will remain at or very close to $100,000. It is possible that COPS funding levels for larger agencies will be reduced, due to the state’s fiscal crisis.
Many police departments use the grant funds to pay for additional sworn police personnel. For the past five years, Carmel-by-the-Sea has used most of its COPS grant funds to pay salary and benefits of one police officer, with the residual funds used to pay for crime prevention strategies.
STAFF REVIEW:
Staff recommends the COPS grant funds be allocated to continue funding the salary and benefits of one (1) full-time police officer for FY 2011-12 which is projected to be $108,525. Because this cost exceeds the grant allocation, the city must contribute local funds, estimated to be $8,525 minus the accrued interest.
Refer to Attachment “A” for summary of cost information.
The grant-funded police officer position supports the Department’s ability to maintain and schedule adequate patrol staffing levels and prevents an already excessive overtime budget from further increases.
FISCAL IMPACT:
Revenue up to $100,000 plus accrued interest. No match is required for receipt or expenditure of this grant, but City funds in the amount of $8,525 will be budgeted in FY 11-12 to ensure one police officer position is sufficiently funded. All grant proceeds, including interest, will be deposited with the City and will be expended in accordance to grant regulations.
SUMMARY:
Utilization of the grant funds will be a benefit to the community and Police Department by enhancing police operations. Approving this Resolution allows the Police Department to expend COPS grant funds in accordance with the requirements of the grant in order to achieve the highest commitment of service to the community.
ATTACHMENT “A”
FY 11-12 COPS GRANT SPENDING PROGRAM
RECOMMENDED PROGRAMS
1) Continued funding of one (1) additional police officer position:
Continue to fund one (1) full-time police officer position to supplement FY 11-12 general
fund authorized positions. As has been the case in previous years, this will be a
“contract” position, subject to the continuation of COPS grant funding.
Grant funds……………………. $ 100,000 plus interest
City funds not to exceed………. $ 8,525
Total project funds…………… $ 108,525*
*All funds must be spent by June 30, 2012.
35
CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
CITY COUNCIL
RESOLUTION 2010-
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA AUTHORIZING THE EXPENDITURE OF THE
CALIFORNIA CITIZENS’ OPTION FOR PUBLIC SAFETY (COPS) GRANT
FUNDS FOR FY 2011-2012
________________________________________________________________________
WHEREAS, pursuant to Senate Bill (SB) 76, the City of Carmel-by-the-Sea
receives in FY 2011-2012 an allocation of $100,000 as a grant from the Citizen Option
for Public Safety (COPS) from the State of California; and
WHEREAS, Senate Bill (SB 76) prohibits the County Auditor from transferring
monies to a recipient agency until the County Supplemental Law Enforcement Oversight
Committee (SLEOC) certifies receipt of an expenditure plan approved by the governing
board of the agency pursuant to a public hearing; and
WHEREAS, the Carmel Police Department has recommended a program to
benefit front-line law enforcement; and
WHEREAS, the Monterey County SLEOC has the authority to review and
approve the proposed spending plan conforms to State Law; and
WHEREAS, public safety will be enhanced by the program.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED THAT THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY
OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA DOES:
1. Declare that all Citizen’s Option for Public Safety (COPS) program funds will
be expended as described in Attachment “A”, for the exclusive purpose of
providing provide front-line law enforcement services, supplementing existing
services, and will not be used to supplant any existing funding for law
enforcement services provided by the City of Carmel-by-the-Sea.
2. Authorize the City of Carmel-by-the-Sea to accept FY 2011-12 COPS grant
funds to be transferred to the City General Fund account 01-87543 for Police
Department expenses related to funding one police officer.
3. Spend grant funds on or before June 30, 2012.
4. Authorize Carmel’s FY 2011-12 Supplemental Law Enforcement Spending
Plan, as proposed in the recitals above, to be submitted to the Supplemental
Law Enforcement Oversight Committee for final approval.
PASSED AND ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA this 5th day of October, 2010, by the following roll call vote:
AYES: COUNCIL MEMBERS:
NOES: COUNCIL MEMBERS:
ABSENT: COUNCIL MEMBERS:
SIGNED:
______________________
SUE McCLOUD, MAYOR
ATTEST:
___________________
Heidi Burch, City Clerk
Prepared by: Sgt. Mel Mukai
City Council
Agenda Item Summary
Name: Consideration of a Resolution authorizing the allocation and expenditure of the California Citizens’ Option for Public Safety (COPS) grant funds for Fiscal Year 2011-2012.
Description: State Senate Bill (SB 76) provides the City of Carmel-by-the-Sea a $100,000
allocation in grant funds under a public safety grant known as the California Citizens’
Option for Public Safety (COPS). The total cost for one police officer position, including
salary and benefits, exceeds the grant allocation. Consequently, the officer’s annual
compensation must be funded in part by local funds.
Overall Cost:
FY 11-12
City Funds: $ 8,525 or less
Grant Funds: $ 100,000 (plus interest)
Staff Recommendation:
Staff recommends adoption of the proposed Resolution.
Important Considerations:
Adoption of the proposed Resolution allows the funding of one police officer position that will be assigned to front-line patrol.
Decision Record:
Resolution 2009-61 approved by Council on September 1, 2009, authorizing the FY 2010-11 expenditure for COPS funds for one police officer position.
Reviewed by:
_________________________________ _____________________
Rich Guillen, City Administrator Date
CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
STAFF REPORT
TO: MAYOR MCCLOUD AND COUNCIL MEMBERS
THROUGH: RICH GUILLEN, CITY ADMINISTRATOR
FROM: MEL MUKAI, SERGEANT
MIKE CALHOUN, COMMANDER
GEORGE E. RAWSON, PUBLIC SAFETY DIRECTOR
DATE: SEPTEMBER 21, 2010
SUBJECT: CONSIDERATION OF A RESOLUTION TO ACCEPT THE FISCAL YEAR 2011-12 CALIFORNIA’S CITIZENS’ OPTION FOR PUBLIC SAFETY (COPS) GRANT FUNDS AND APPROVE THE PROPOSED SPENDING PLAN
RECOMMENDED MOTION:
Adopt the Resolution.
BACKGROUND:
The Citizens’ Options for Public Safety (COPS) Program was signed into law by Governor Gray Davis on July 6, 2000. The COPS program established a "Supplemental Law Enforcement Special Fund” (SLESF), which annually allocates entitlement grants to cities and counties to augment public safety. The grant amounts vary, based on population. Historically, smaller communities such as Carmel-by-the-Sea receive a minimum fixed amount of $100,000.
COPS funds cannot be remitted until certain processes are completed, as required by Government Code § 30061 – 30065. These statutes require the Director of Public Safety to propose a spending plan and submit it to City Council for review.
The Council must hold a public hearing, allow for public comment, and adopt the spending plan by Resolution. After City Council ratification, the Resolution is forwarded to the County of Monterey Supplemental Law Enforcement Oversight Committee (SLEOC), which reviews and certifies that the spending plan complies with the above referenced Government code requirements. SLESF funds are restricted to front-line municipal police services and must supplement, not
supplant, current, front-line law enforcement services. Funds must be encumbered or spent within the two-year grant cycle. Any unspent funds must be remanded back to the state via the County Auditor’s office.
It is anticipated the State of California will again approve the Citizens’ Option for Public Safety (COPS) grant funds for FY 11-12. The state legislature has not yet adopted the final budget, but it is probable that the minimum awards for smaller communities will remain at or very close to $100,000. It is possible that COPS funding levels for larger agencies will be reduced, due to the state’s fiscal crisis.
Many police departments use the grant funds to pay for additional sworn police personnel. For the past five years, Carmel-by-the-Sea has used most of its COPS grant funds to pay salary and benefits of one police officer, with the residual funds used to pay for crime prevention strategies.
STAFF REVIEW:
Staff recommends the COPS grant funds be allocated to continue funding the salary and benefits of one (1) full-time police officer for FY 2011-12 which is projected to be $108,525. Because this cost exceeds the grant allocation, the city must contribute local funds, estimated to be $8,525 minus the accrued interest.
Refer to Attachment “A” for summary of cost information.
The grant-funded police officer position supports the Department’s ability to maintain and schedule adequate patrol staffing levels and prevents an already excessive overtime budget from further increases.
FISCAL IMPACT:
Revenue up to $100,000 plus accrued interest. No match is required for receipt or expenditure of this grant, but City funds in the amount of $8,525 will be budgeted in FY 11-12 to ensure one police officer position is sufficiently funded. All grant proceeds, including interest, will be deposited with the City and will be expended in accordance to grant regulations.
SUMMARY:
Utilization of the grant funds will be a benefit to the community and Police Department by enhancing police operations. Approving this Resolution allows the Police Department to expend COPS grant funds in accordance with the requirements of the grant in order to achieve the highest commitment of service to the community.
ATTACHMENT “A”
FY 11-12 COPS GRANT SPENDING PROGRAM
RECOMMENDED PROGRAMS
1) Continued funding of one (1) additional police officer position:
Continue to fund one (1) full-time police officer position to supplement FY 11-12 general
fund authorized positions. As has been the case in previous years, this will be a
“contract” position, subject to the continuation of COPS grant funding.
Grant funds……………………. $ 100,000 plus interest
City funds not to exceed………. $ 8,525
Total project funds…………… $ 108,525*
*All funds must be spent by June 30, 2012.
35
CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
CITY COUNCIL
RESOLUTION 2010-
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA AUTHORIZING THE EXPENDITURE OF THE
CALIFORNIA CITIZENS’ OPTION FOR PUBLIC SAFETY (COPS) GRANT
FUNDS FOR FY 2011-2012
________________________________________________________________________
WHEREAS, pursuant to Senate Bill (SB) 76, the City of Carmel-by-the-Sea
receives in FY 2011-2012 an allocation of $100,000 as a grant from the Citizen Option
for Public Safety (COPS) from the State of California; and
WHEREAS, Senate Bill (SB 76) prohibits the County Auditor from transferring
monies to a recipient agency until the County Supplemental Law Enforcement Oversight
Committee (SLEOC) certifies receipt of an expenditure plan approved by the governing
board of the agency pursuant to a public hearing; and
WHEREAS, the Carmel Police Department has recommended a program to
benefit front-line law enforcement; and
WHEREAS, the Monterey County SLEOC has the authority to review and
approve the proposed spending plan conforms to State Law; and
WHEREAS, public safety will be enhanced by the program.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED THAT THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY
OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA DOES:
1. Declare that all Citizen’s Option for Public Safety (COPS) program funds will
be expended as described in Attachment “A”, for the exclusive purpose of
providing provide front-line law enforcement services, supplementing existing
services, and will not be used to supplant any existing funding for law
enforcement services provided by the City of Carmel-by-the-Sea.
2. Authorize the City of Carmel-by-the-Sea to accept FY 2011-12 COPS grant
funds to be transferred to the City General Fund account 01-87543 for Police
Department expenses related to funding one police officer.
3. Spend grant funds on or before June 30, 2012.
4. Authorize Carmel’s FY 2011-12 Supplemental Law Enforcement Spending
Plan, as proposed in the recitals above, to be submitted to the Supplemental
Law Enforcement Oversight Committee for final approval.
PASSED AND ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA this 5th day of October, 2010, by the following roll call vote:
AYES: COUNCIL MEMBERS:
NOES: COUNCIL MEMBERS:
ABSENT: COUNCIL MEMBERS:
SIGNED:
______________________
SUE McCLOUD, MAYOR
ATTEST:
___________________
Heidi Burch, City Clerk
Labels:
Agenda Item Summary,
Resolution,
Staff Report
CITY COUNCIL: Request to Amend Carmel Municipal Code to Allow for the Keeping of Chickens
Meeting Date: 5 October 2010
Prepared by: Sean Conroy, Plng & Bldg Services Manager
City Council
Agenda Item Summary
Name: Consideration of a request to amend Carmel Municipal Code Section 6.08.120 to allow for the keeping of chickens in the City of Carmel-by-the-Sea. The applicant is Anna Yateman.
Description: The applicant is requesting that the Municipal Code be amended to allow the
keeping of chickens in the City. The applicant is requesting to keep two hens on her
property.
Overall Cost:
City Funds: N/A
Grant Funds: N/A
Staff Recommendation: Deny the application.
Important Considerations: The City has not allowed the keeping of chickens within City
limits since 1969. Allowing chickens could impact the residential character of the City
and increase the workload of the animal control department.
Decision Record: The Planning Commission recommended that the City allow the keeping of
chickens on 11 August 2010.
Reviewed by:
__________________________ _____________________
Rich Guillen, City Administrator Date
CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY PLANNING AND BUILDING
STAFF REPORT
TO: MAYOR MCCLOUD AND COUNCIL MEMBERS
FROM: SEAN CONROY, PLNG & BLDG SERVICES MANAGER
DATE: 5 OCTOBER 2010
SUBJECT: CONSIDERATION OF A REQUEST TO AMEND MUNICIPAL CODE SECTION 6.08.120 TO ALLOW FOR THE KEEPING OF CHICKENS IN THE CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA. THE APPLICANT IS ANNA YATEMAN
BACKGROUND & DESCRIPTION
Carmel Municipal Code (CMC) Section 6 establishes the City’s regulations regarding animals. Section 6.08.120, originally adopted in 1969, states the following:
“It is unlawful, and is declared a nuisance, for any person or persons to keep or cause to be kept any swine or barnyard fowl whatsoever within the corporate limits of the City.”
The applicant is requesting permission to keep two hens on her property. Since the keeping of chickens is prohibited, the applicant is requesting that the municipal code be amended. The applicant is also requesting that the $420 application fee be waived.
EVALUATION
Process: Staff has not prepared an ordinance amendment for Council review at this time. If the Council determines that the Municipal Code should be amended, then staff would prepare a draft ordinance for review at a future hearing. If the Council determines that the Municipal Code should not be amended, no further action is required.
Planning Commission: On 11 August 2010 the Planning Commission recommended that the Council amend the Municipal Code to allow for the keeping of chickens. The Commission recommended the following requirements be included in any new ordinance amendment:
• Require a Conditional Use Permit (CUP)
• Limit it to the keeping of hens, not roosters
• Require all fowl to be maintained in an enclosure of chicken wire or other suitable
material
• Establish a limit on the number of fowl on any one property
• Limit it to the R-1 District
Staff does not support amending the Municipal Code for the following reasons:
1) Residential Character: The City is predominately a residential village set in a forest.
However, the rustic residential character does not equate to a rural setting. With small
lots and minimal setbacks between dwellings, the neighborhoods are relatively dense for
a single-family zone. One of the primary purposes of the current standards related to
fowl is to avoid uses that are more appropriate for larger, rural lots. Allowing chickens
could lead to requests to allow other barnyard fowl and/or swine, and could result in
diminishing the residential character of the City.
2) Animal Control: Allowing chickens could attract more wild animals into the city, particularly raccoons. Raccoons already present a challenge to Carmel residents and pets, as they can be quite aggressive. If numerous residents began keeping chickens, this could result in an increase in the number of raccoons or other predators coming into the City. The City has only one part-time animal control officer, who is already heavily burdened with animal control issues. Allowing the keeping of chickens would likely add to the enforcement burden on the City.
3) Public Health: If the City began allowing chickens, and numerous residents began
keeping them, several public health concerns could arise. While staff has not performed
a thorough public health analysis, some of the common health concerns related to the
raising of chickens include:
• The transfer of bacteria, particularly Salmonella
• High levels of arsenic that can often be found in many types of chicken feed
• Potential water quality issues related to animal waste and storm water run-off
Other Communities: Some neighboring communities, including Monterey and Pacific
Grove, do allow the keeping of chickens (see attached ordinances). While these
communities have many small lots similar to Carmel, they also have many larger lots
where the keeping of chickens may be more appropriate.
The Police Department did speak with an official with the City of Pacific Grove who
indicated that they have had problems with predators, such as raccoons and skunks,
attacking chickens. They have also had incidents of chickens either escaping from a
particular property or being discarded by their owner, which creates additional animal
control issues.
Fee Waiver: The applicant has requested that the City Council waive the application fee
for this project. Staff does not support the fee waiver as there are costs involved in
amending the Municipal Code. Costs include staff time for preparing a draft ordinance,
public notices, staff reports, and other documents along with costs associated with
publishing public notices and Municipal Code amendments. If the Council directs staff
to prepare an ordinance for future review by the Council, staff recommends that the
application fee be submitted prior to any further work on this project.
RECOMMENDATION
Deny the request to amend the Municipal Code.
Chicken Run Rescue
WILDLIFE
Monterey sea otters killed by toxic algae
September 11, 2010|By Peter Fimrite, Chronicle Staff Writer
A toxic algae that forms in reservoirs, lakes and stagnant freshwater ponds was responsible for the deaths of at least 21 threatened California sea otters in the Monterey Bay area, a scientific study revealed Friday.
The discovery, reported in the scientific journal PLoS ONE, is alarming because the toxin, called microcystin, had never been linked to the death of a marine mammal and was not believed to be capable of surviving for long periods in saltwater.
"Based on what we know, this is the first documentation of a freshwater algal bloom being transmitted to upper-level marine mammals, specifically a federally listed species," said Melissa Miller, a senior wildlife veterinarian and pathologist for the California Department of Fish and Game and the study's lead author.
The three-year average population of California otters, also known as southern sea otters, declined 3.6 percent this year, the second consecutive drop after a decade of increases. The reason for the decline is a mystery, but scientists believe a variety of causes are at play, including toxic runoff.
There are 2,711 sea otters along the California coast, according to a U.S. Geological Survey study, which also reported an 11 percent drop in the number of otter pups compared with last year.
Study points to algae
Microcystin, which is commonly referred to as blue-green algae, can cause liver damage when ingested. All 21 sea otters that tested positive for the bacteria died from liver failure, according to the study, which was completed with the help of experts from UC Santa Cruz and a variety of state and federal agencies.
It is believed the toxins flowed to the ocean off the coast of Monterey in rivers and creeks. Sea urchins and shellfish near the outflow filtered the water and the poison accumulated in their bodies, which were, in turn, eaten by otters.
It has not yet been determined whether poisoning from blue-green algae is playing a major or minor role in the overall otter decline, but it was at least a factor, the researchers said. The 21 sea otters represent only a fraction of the number of mammals found dead from unknown causes along the Central California coast since 1999. Miller said the full extent of the problem will not be known until further studies can be conducted.
Microcystis is a naturally occurring algae. Its bright green blooms have long been found behind dams, particularly along the Klamath River, and in stagnant pools.
Global concern
But researchers say the microcystin toxin appears to be multiplying in the environment to the point that it is becoming a global health concern. That's because cyanobacteria, as scientists call bacterial blooms, thrive in warm water that is rich in nutrients from lawn, city and agricultural runoff. The warmer the temperatures, the more bacteria there are
Global warming, scientists say, has increased the frequency of deadly green "super-blooms."
Microcystins have been detected in brackish water before, including in the Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta and San Francisco Bay, scientists say. The bacteria has been linked to the death of cattle and even dogs that drank the water or swam through the green slime and then licked their fur. It is also potentially dangerous to humans.
"What's really astonishing to us is that it had not been on anyone's radar as a problem in the marine environments until now," said co-author Tim Tinker, a research biologist with the U.S. Geological Survey and an adjunct professor of ecology and evolutionary biology at UC Santa Cruz.
The problem was discovered largely by mistake. In 2007, Miller kept running across the bloated, bright yellow corpses of otters near Monterey Bay, indicating acute liver failure. She searched medical journals for things that might have caused the problem and found nothing that fit until she came across blue-green algae.
Suspicions confirmed
Tissue samples confirmed her suspicion. The team of scientists she recruited eventually found high concentrations of microcystin in lakes bordering Monterey Bay and in adjacent rivers.
Blooms were also found in Pinto Lake in Watsonville, which drains into Corralitos Creek and flows into the Pajaro River. Microcystin contamination was eventually detected in the Salinas, Pajaro and San Lorenzo rivers and in the ocean at the Santa Cruz wharf.
The study found that the algae remains extremely toxic for two weeks in the ocean and that the poison can become 107 times more concentrated in shellfish. That means it is a risk to humans who consume shellfish harvested near river mouths. There are no state or federal regulations for exposure to microcystin.
"This definitely highlights the importance of monitoring water quality," Tinker said. "Here is a toxin coming into the ocean, probably affecting a lot of species, and the first indication we have of it is the death of sea otters. It is an early warning for an emerging problem."
E-mail Peter Fimrite at pfimrite@sfchronicle.com.
(C) San Francisco Chronicle 2010
Prepared by: Sean Conroy, Plng & Bldg Services Manager
City Council
Agenda Item Summary
Name: Consideration of a request to amend Carmel Municipal Code Section 6.08.120 to allow for the keeping of chickens in the City of Carmel-by-the-Sea. The applicant is Anna Yateman.
Description: The applicant is requesting that the Municipal Code be amended to allow the
keeping of chickens in the City. The applicant is requesting to keep two hens on her
property.
Overall Cost:
City Funds: N/A
Grant Funds: N/A
Staff Recommendation: Deny the application.
Important Considerations: The City has not allowed the keeping of chickens within City
limits since 1969. Allowing chickens could impact the residential character of the City
and increase the workload of the animal control department.
Decision Record: The Planning Commission recommended that the City allow the keeping of
chickens on 11 August 2010.
Reviewed by:
__________________________ _____________________
Rich Guillen, City Administrator Date
CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY PLANNING AND BUILDING
STAFF REPORT
TO: MAYOR MCCLOUD AND COUNCIL MEMBERS
FROM: SEAN CONROY, PLNG & BLDG SERVICES MANAGER
DATE: 5 OCTOBER 2010
SUBJECT: CONSIDERATION OF A REQUEST TO AMEND MUNICIPAL CODE SECTION 6.08.120 TO ALLOW FOR THE KEEPING OF CHICKENS IN THE CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA. THE APPLICANT IS ANNA YATEMAN
BACKGROUND & DESCRIPTION
Carmel Municipal Code (CMC) Section 6 establishes the City’s regulations regarding animals. Section 6.08.120, originally adopted in 1969, states the following:
“It is unlawful, and is declared a nuisance, for any person or persons to keep or cause to be kept any swine or barnyard fowl whatsoever within the corporate limits of the City.”
The applicant is requesting permission to keep two hens on her property. Since the keeping of chickens is prohibited, the applicant is requesting that the municipal code be amended. The applicant is also requesting that the $420 application fee be waived.
EVALUATION
Process: Staff has not prepared an ordinance amendment for Council review at this time. If the Council determines that the Municipal Code should be amended, then staff would prepare a draft ordinance for review at a future hearing. If the Council determines that the Municipal Code should not be amended, no further action is required.
Planning Commission: On 11 August 2010 the Planning Commission recommended that the Council amend the Municipal Code to allow for the keeping of chickens. The Commission recommended the following requirements be included in any new ordinance amendment:
• Require a Conditional Use Permit (CUP)
• Limit it to the keeping of hens, not roosters
• Require all fowl to be maintained in an enclosure of chicken wire or other suitable
material
• Establish a limit on the number of fowl on any one property
• Limit it to the R-1 District
Staff does not support amending the Municipal Code for the following reasons:
1) Residential Character: The City is predominately a residential village set in a forest.
However, the rustic residential character does not equate to a rural setting. With small
lots and minimal setbacks between dwellings, the neighborhoods are relatively dense for
a single-family zone. One of the primary purposes of the current standards related to
fowl is to avoid uses that are more appropriate for larger, rural lots. Allowing chickens
could lead to requests to allow other barnyard fowl and/or swine, and could result in
diminishing the residential character of the City.
2) Animal Control: Allowing chickens could attract more wild animals into the city, particularly raccoons. Raccoons already present a challenge to Carmel residents and pets, as they can be quite aggressive. If numerous residents began keeping chickens, this could result in an increase in the number of raccoons or other predators coming into the City. The City has only one part-time animal control officer, who is already heavily burdened with animal control issues. Allowing the keeping of chickens would likely add to the enforcement burden on the City.
3) Public Health: If the City began allowing chickens, and numerous residents began
keeping them, several public health concerns could arise. While staff has not performed
a thorough public health analysis, some of the common health concerns related to the
raising of chickens include:
• The transfer of bacteria, particularly Salmonella
• High levels of arsenic that can often be found in many types of chicken feed
• Potential water quality issues related to animal waste and storm water run-off
Other Communities: Some neighboring communities, including Monterey and Pacific
Grove, do allow the keeping of chickens (see attached ordinances). While these
communities have many small lots similar to Carmel, they also have many larger lots
where the keeping of chickens may be more appropriate.
The Police Department did speak with an official with the City of Pacific Grove who
indicated that they have had problems with predators, such as raccoons and skunks,
attacking chickens. They have also had incidents of chickens either escaping from a
particular property or being discarded by their owner, which creates additional animal
control issues.
Fee Waiver: The applicant has requested that the City Council waive the application fee
for this project. Staff does not support the fee waiver as there are costs involved in
amending the Municipal Code. Costs include staff time for preparing a draft ordinance,
public notices, staff reports, and other documents along with costs associated with
publishing public notices and Municipal Code amendments. If the Council directs staff
to prepare an ordinance for future review by the Council, staff recommends that the
application fee be submitted prior to any further work on this project.
RECOMMENDATION
Deny the request to amend the Municipal Code.
Chicken Run Rescue
WILDLIFE
Monterey sea otters killed by toxic algae
September 11, 2010|By Peter Fimrite, Chronicle Staff Writer
A toxic algae that forms in reservoirs, lakes and stagnant freshwater ponds was responsible for the deaths of at least 21 threatened California sea otters in the Monterey Bay area, a scientific study revealed Friday.
The discovery, reported in the scientific journal PLoS ONE, is alarming because the toxin, called microcystin, had never been linked to the death of a marine mammal and was not believed to be capable of surviving for long periods in saltwater.
"Based on what we know, this is the first documentation of a freshwater algal bloom being transmitted to upper-level marine mammals, specifically a federally listed species," said Melissa Miller, a senior wildlife veterinarian and pathologist for the California Department of Fish and Game and the study's lead author.
The three-year average population of California otters, also known as southern sea otters, declined 3.6 percent this year, the second consecutive drop after a decade of increases. The reason for the decline is a mystery, but scientists believe a variety of causes are at play, including toxic runoff.
There are 2,711 sea otters along the California coast, according to a U.S. Geological Survey study, which also reported an 11 percent drop in the number of otter pups compared with last year.
Study points to algae
Microcystin, which is commonly referred to as blue-green algae, can cause liver damage when ingested. All 21 sea otters that tested positive for the bacteria died from liver failure, according to the study, which was completed with the help of experts from UC Santa Cruz and a variety of state and federal agencies.
It is believed the toxins flowed to the ocean off the coast of Monterey in rivers and creeks. Sea urchins and shellfish near the outflow filtered the water and the poison accumulated in their bodies, which were, in turn, eaten by otters.
It has not yet been determined whether poisoning from blue-green algae is playing a major or minor role in the overall otter decline, but it was at least a factor, the researchers said. The 21 sea otters represent only a fraction of the number of mammals found dead from unknown causes along the Central California coast since 1999. Miller said the full extent of the problem will not be known until further studies can be conducted.
Microcystis is a naturally occurring algae. Its bright green blooms have long been found behind dams, particularly along the Klamath River, and in stagnant pools.
Global concern
But researchers say the microcystin toxin appears to be multiplying in the environment to the point that it is becoming a global health concern. That's because cyanobacteria, as scientists call bacterial blooms, thrive in warm water that is rich in nutrients from lawn, city and agricultural runoff. The warmer the temperatures, the more bacteria there are
Global warming, scientists say, has increased the frequency of deadly green "super-blooms."
Microcystins have been detected in brackish water before, including in the Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta and San Francisco Bay, scientists say. The bacteria has been linked to the death of cattle and even dogs that drank the water or swam through the green slime and then licked their fur. It is also potentially dangerous to humans.
"What's really astonishing to us is that it had not been on anyone's radar as a problem in the marine environments until now," said co-author Tim Tinker, a research biologist with the U.S. Geological Survey and an adjunct professor of ecology and evolutionary biology at UC Santa Cruz.
The problem was discovered largely by mistake. In 2007, Miller kept running across the bloated, bright yellow corpses of otters near Monterey Bay, indicating acute liver failure. She searched medical journals for things that might have caused the problem and found nothing that fit until she came across blue-green algae.
Suspicions confirmed
Tissue samples confirmed her suspicion. The team of scientists she recruited eventually found high concentrations of microcystin in lakes bordering Monterey Bay and in adjacent rivers.
Blooms were also found in Pinto Lake in Watsonville, which drains into Corralitos Creek and flows into the Pajaro River. Microcystin contamination was eventually detected in the Salinas, Pajaro and San Lorenzo rivers and in the ocean at the Santa Cruz wharf.
The study found that the algae remains extremely toxic for two weeks in the ocean and that the poison can become 107 times more concentrated in shellfish. That means it is a risk to humans who consume shellfish harvested near river mouths. There are no state or federal regulations for exposure to microcystin.
"This definitely highlights the importance of monitoring water quality," Tinker said. "Here is a toxin coming into the ocean, probably affecting a lot of species, and the first indication we have of it is the death of sea otters. It is an early warning for an emerging problem."
E-mail Peter Fimrite at pfimrite@sfchronicle.com.
(C) San Francisco Chronicle 2010
CITY COUNCIL: Windows Committee & Planning Commission Recommendations regarding City's Policy on Residential Window Applications
Meeting Date: 5 October 2010
Prepared by: Marc Wiener, Associate Planner
City Council
Agenda Item Summary
Name: Consideration of recommendations from the Window Committee and Planning Commission regarding the City’s policy on residential window applications.
Description: Presentation of Window Committee findings and review of Carmel’s Residential
Design Guidelines with regards to window materials.
Overall Cost:
City Funds: N/A
Grant Funds: N/A
Staff Recommendation: Provide policy direction on whether the City should allow aluminum
clad wood windows.
Important Considerations: Design Guideline 9.11 states that “materials other than authentic,
unclad wood are appropriate only when it can be demonstrated that the proposed material is more appropriate to the architecture.” The Planning Commission appointed a Windows Committee to review the issue of whether the City should allow aluminum clad wood windows. The Committee
recommended that the City not allow aluminum clad wood windows.
Decision Record: The Planning Commission recommended that the Design Guidelines not be
amended to allow the use of aluminum clad wood windows on 14 April 2010.
Reviewed by:
__________________________ _____________________
Rich Guillen, City Administrator Date
CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
STAFF REPORT
TO: MAYOR McCLOUD AND COUNCIL MEMBERS
THROUGH: RICH GUILLEN, CITY ADMINISTRATOR
FROM: MARC WIENER, ASSOCIATE PLANNER
DATE: 5 OCTOBER 2010
SUBJECT: CONSIDERATION OF RECOMMENDATIONS FROM THE WINDOW COMMITTEE AND PLANNING COMMISSION
REGARDING THE CITY’S POLICY ON RESIDENTIAL WINDOW APPLICATIONS
BACKGROUND
Window styles and materials play a vital role in the residential character of the City.
The Residential Design Guidelines strongly encourage the use of unclad wood windows
for most residential projects. With regards to window materials, Residential Design
Guideline 9.11 states, “materials other than authentic, unclad wood are appropriate only
when it can be demonstrated that the proposed material is more appropriate to the
architecture.” The Guidelines also encourage the use of natural building materials.
ISSUE
In recent years more and more applicants are requesting approval to use aluminum clad
wood windows. The Design Review Board (now dissolved), Planning Commission and
City Council have all approved aluminum clad wood windows on a number of occasions.
The approval of aluminum clad windows has typically been based on the opinion that
clad windows often appear very similar to wood aesthetically.
Recently, the Planning Commission has questioned the wisdom of approving aluminum
clad wood windows. The Commission appointed a four member Window Committee in
January 2010 to review the issue in more depth and to provide recommendations on
whether the City should approve aluminum clad wood windows. The Committee
prepared the attached report (exhibit “A”) that was presented to the Planning Commission
on 14 April 2010. The Green Building Committee reviewed the Window Committee’s
report and submitted the attached memo to the City Council (exhibit “B”).
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATIONS
Window Committee: Regarding aesthetics, the Committee determined that when
initially installed, some aluminum clad wood windows can be difficult to distinguish
72
Window Committee
5 October 2010
Staff Report
Page 2
from unclad wood windows, particularly from a distance. However, the Committee has
significant concerns about the long-term appearance of the aluminum clad wood
windows.
In many instances, aluminum clad windows cannot be painted without voiding the
warranty. While some clad windows can appear very similar to wood windows when
initially installed, it is unclear how they will look in the long run as the exterior finish
may fade or degrade over time. It is questionable as to whether clad windows can easily
be repainted.
In contrast, wood windows can be varnished, oiled and/or painted regularly to maintain a
quality appearance over time. Additionally, a wood window that has been varnished or
oiled presents a natural wood-grain appearance that is not possible with an aluminum
clad window.
The Committee concluded that the Design Guidelines should remain as written and that
unclad wood windows should continue to be the preferred window material for most
projects in the City. The Planning Commission concurred with the findings and
recommendations of the Committee on 14 April 2010.
Green Building Committee (GBC): The GBC supports allowing aluminum clad wood
windows as they 1) provide home owners with options, 2) are aesthetically
indistinguishable from wood windows, and 3) are considered a low maintenance product.
COUNCIL REVIEW
The Council should review the reports from the committees and answer the following
questions:
• Should the City allow the use of aluminum clad wood windows? If yes,
• Should the Design Guidelines be amended accordingly?
The Window Committee’s report addresses a wide range of issues including cost,
maintenance, environmental factors, appearance etc. While these topics help to inform
the City Council, staff recommends that the Council’s primary focus should be on the
aesthetic aspects of wood windows versus clad windows.
RECOMMENDATION:
Provide policy direction on whether the City should allow the use of aluminum clad
wood windows.
Prepared by: Marc Wiener, Associate Planner
City Council
Agenda Item Summary
Name: Consideration of recommendations from the Window Committee and Planning Commission regarding the City’s policy on residential window applications.
Description: Presentation of Window Committee findings and review of Carmel’s Residential
Design Guidelines with regards to window materials.
Overall Cost:
City Funds: N/A
Grant Funds: N/A
Staff Recommendation: Provide policy direction on whether the City should allow aluminum
clad wood windows.
Important Considerations: Design Guideline 9.11 states that “materials other than authentic,
unclad wood are appropriate only when it can be demonstrated that the proposed material is more appropriate to the architecture.” The Planning Commission appointed a Windows Committee to review the issue of whether the City should allow aluminum clad wood windows. The Committee
recommended that the City not allow aluminum clad wood windows.
Decision Record: The Planning Commission recommended that the Design Guidelines not be
amended to allow the use of aluminum clad wood windows on 14 April 2010.
Reviewed by:
__________________________ _____________________
Rich Guillen, City Administrator Date
CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
STAFF REPORT
TO: MAYOR McCLOUD AND COUNCIL MEMBERS
THROUGH: RICH GUILLEN, CITY ADMINISTRATOR
FROM: MARC WIENER, ASSOCIATE PLANNER
DATE: 5 OCTOBER 2010
SUBJECT: CONSIDERATION OF RECOMMENDATIONS FROM THE WINDOW COMMITTEE AND PLANNING COMMISSION
REGARDING THE CITY’S POLICY ON RESIDENTIAL WINDOW APPLICATIONS
BACKGROUND
Window styles and materials play a vital role in the residential character of the City.
The Residential Design Guidelines strongly encourage the use of unclad wood windows
for most residential projects. With regards to window materials, Residential Design
Guideline 9.11 states, “materials other than authentic, unclad wood are appropriate only
when it can be demonstrated that the proposed material is more appropriate to the
architecture.” The Guidelines also encourage the use of natural building materials.
ISSUE
In recent years more and more applicants are requesting approval to use aluminum clad
wood windows. The Design Review Board (now dissolved), Planning Commission and
City Council have all approved aluminum clad wood windows on a number of occasions.
The approval of aluminum clad windows has typically been based on the opinion that
clad windows often appear very similar to wood aesthetically.
Recently, the Planning Commission has questioned the wisdom of approving aluminum
clad wood windows. The Commission appointed a four member Window Committee in
January 2010 to review the issue in more depth and to provide recommendations on
whether the City should approve aluminum clad wood windows. The Committee
prepared the attached report (exhibit “A”) that was presented to the Planning Commission
on 14 April 2010. The Green Building Committee reviewed the Window Committee’s
report and submitted the attached memo to the City Council (exhibit “B”).
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATIONS
Window Committee: Regarding aesthetics, the Committee determined that when
initially installed, some aluminum clad wood windows can be difficult to distinguish
72
Window Committee
5 October 2010
Staff Report
Page 2
from unclad wood windows, particularly from a distance. However, the Committee has
significant concerns about the long-term appearance of the aluminum clad wood
windows.
In many instances, aluminum clad windows cannot be painted without voiding the
warranty. While some clad windows can appear very similar to wood windows when
initially installed, it is unclear how they will look in the long run as the exterior finish
may fade or degrade over time. It is questionable as to whether clad windows can easily
be repainted.
In contrast, wood windows can be varnished, oiled and/or painted regularly to maintain a
quality appearance over time. Additionally, a wood window that has been varnished or
oiled presents a natural wood-grain appearance that is not possible with an aluminum
clad window.
The Committee concluded that the Design Guidelines should remain as written and that
unclad wood windows should continue to be the preferred window material for most
projects in the City. The Planning Commission concurred with the findings and
recommendations of the Committee on 14 April 2010.
Green Building Committee (GBC): The GBC supports allowing aluminum clad wood
windows as they 1) provide home owners with options, 2) are aesthetically
indistinguishable from wood windows, and 3) are considered a low maintenance product.
COUNCIL REVIEW
The Council should review the reports from the committees and answer the following
questions:
• Should the City allow the use of aluminum clad wood windows? If yes,
• Should the Design Guidelines be amended accordingly?
The Window Committee’s report addresses a wide range of issues including cost,
maintenance, environmental factors, appearance etc. While these topics help to inform
the City Council, staff recommends that the Council’s primary focus should be on the
aesthetic aspects of wood windows versus clad windows.
RECOMMENDATION:
Provide policy direction on whether the City should allow the use of aluminum clad
wood windows.
CITY COUNCIL: Report & Council Direction on Options for the 2012 Municipal Election
Meeting Date: October 5, 2010
Prepared by: Heidi Burch, City Clerk
City Council
Agenda Item Summary
Name: Receive report and provide Council direction on options for the 2012 Municipal
Election.
Description: Staff is requesting direction regarding whether the City should continue to conduct
a standalone election for the Mayoral and Council seats in April or consolidate with the
County’s November General Election.
Overall Cost:
City Funds: see staff report for cost estimates
Grant Funds: N/A
Staff Recommendation: Provide staff direction.
Important Considerations: Contracting with the Monterey County Registrar’s office for
election services for an April election is no longer a viable alternative due to significant
increases in costs.
Decision Record: Council considered this item at its September 14, 2010 meeting. It was
widely decided to continue this item so Council and the public could have more time to
consider the various options.
Reviewed by:
__________________________ _____________________
Rich Guillen, City Administrator Date
CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
STAFF REPORT
TO: MAYOR MCCLOUD AND COUNCIL MEMBERS
FROM: HEIDI BURCH, CITY CLERK
THROUGH: RICH GUILLEN, CITY ADMINISTRATOR
DATE: OCTOBER 5, 2010
SUBJECT: CITY ELECTIONS
INTRODUCTION & BACKGROUND
The City has held its elections in April of even years since its incorporation in 1916. In the past,
the City has contracted with the Monterey County Elections Department to conduct its elections.
Significant cost increases, however, forced the City to conduct its own election in April 2010
rather than contracting with the County. The City contracted with Martin & Chapman to conduct
its election, thereby saving the City between $28,000 and $40,000. (Because the County quotes
varied greatly, savings by the City can only be placed in a range).
In reviewing the City’s 2010 election, the following items were noted:
The City would need to have at least one more experienced poll worker during the closing of the
polls. Poll workers that had previously worked on County elections had been placed at the two
precincts throughout the day. One precinct, however, did not have an experienced poll worker
present for the closing of the polls. This would be remedied going forward as a number of former
poll workers volunteered their services for the 2012 election.
The City’s use of volunteers to set up the polling places, post signage, work at the precincts from
7 a.m. to 8 p.m., close down the polls and reconcile votes placed saved the City thousands of
dollars in costs previously charged by the County.
The results of the election were calculated significantly quicker than during the election in 2008.
Results for the 2010 election were tabulated within 1.5 hours. The final results were available the
next day. By law, the county has 28 days to conduct the canvass and determine the final results
of an election.
82
Staff Report
3 August 2010
Page 2
City staff time to conduct the election did not increase significantly. City staff already had
election duties when contracting with the County. The main additions to those duties in
contracting with Martin & Chapman were the processing of the vote-by-the-mail ballots, which
included the verification of signatures, and duties on the day of the election. Deputy City Clerk,
Molly Laughlin, spent 25 hours and I spent 13 hours verifying signatures, photocopying ballots
and supervising the polls.
As contracting with the County to conduct future elections in April is cost prohibitive, there are
two remaining viable options for future Carmel-by-the-Sea elections. The City can continue to
conduct its election in April of even years or change the election to November and consolidate
with the General Election.
ANTICIPATED COSTS
November consolidated election – County
estimate
$12-$17,000*
Traditional April election –County estimate $50,679
Traditional April election – Martin &
Chapman estimate $23,000
* The City was charged $16,340 by the County for the election in November 2009.
SUMMARY
Contracting with the Monterey County Registrar’s office for election services for an April
election is no longer a viable alternative. Staff requests Council direction to continue contracting
with Martin & Chapman for its April election or to take measures to move the election to
November and consolidate with the County and other agencies.
Prepared by: Heidi Burch, City Clerk
City Council
Agenda Item Summary
Name: Receive report and provide Council direction on options for the 2012 Municipal
Election.
Description: Staff is requesting direction regarding whether the City should continue to conduct
a standalone election for the Mayoral and Council seats in April or consolidate with the
County’s November General Election.
Overall Cost:
City Funds: see staff report for cost estimates
Grant Funds: N/A
Staff Recommendation: Provide staff direction.
Important Considerations: Contracting with the Monterey County Registrar’s office for
election services for an April election is no longer a viable alternative due to significant
increases in costs.
Decision Record: Council considered this item at its September 14, 2010 meeting. It was
widely decided to continue this item so Council and the public could have more time to
consider the various options.
Reviewed by:
__________________________ _____________________
Rich Guillen, City Administrator Date
CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
STAFF REPORT
TO: MAYOR MCCLOUD AND COUNCIL MEMBERS
FROM: HEIDI BURCH, CITY CLERK
THROUGH: RICH GUILLEN, CITY ADMINISTRATOR
DATE: OCTOBER 5, 2010
SUBJECT: CITY ELECTIONS
INTRODUCTION & BACKGROUND
The City has held its elections in April of even years since its incorporation in 1916. In the past,
the City has contracted with the Monterey County Elections Department to conduct its elections.
Significant cost increases, however, forced the City to conduct its own election in April 2010
rather than contracting with the County. The City contracted with Martin & Chapman to conduct
its election, thereby saving the City between $28,000 and $40,000. (Because the County quotes
varied greatly, savings by the City can only be placed in a range).
In reviewing the City’s 2010 election, the following items were noted:
The City would need to have at least one more experienced poll worker during the closing of the
polls. Poll workers that had previously worked on County elections had been placed at the two
precincts throughout the day. One precinct, however, did not have an experienced poll worker
present for the closing of the polls. This would be remedied going forward as a number of former
poll workers volunteered their services for the 2012 election.
The City’s use of volunteers to set up the polling places, post signage, work at the precincts from
7 a.m. to 8 p.m., close down the polls and reconcile votes placed saved the City thousands of
dollars in costs previously charged by the County.
The results of the election were calculated significantly quicker than during the election in 2008.
Results for the 2010 election were tabulated within 1.5 hours. The final results were available the
next day. By law, the county has 28 days to conduct the canvass and determine the final results
of an election.
82
Staff Report
3 August 2010
Page 2
City staff time to conduct the election did not increase significantly. City staff already had
election duties when contracting with the County. The main additions to those duties in
contracting with Martin & Chapman were the processing of the vote-by-the-mail ballots, which
included the verification of signatures, and duties on the day of the election. Deputy City Clerk,
Molly Laughlin, spent 25 hours and I spent 13 hours verifying signatures, photocopying ballots
and supervising the polls.
As contracting with the County to conduct future elections in April is cost prohibitive, there are
two remaining viable options for future Carmel-by-the-Sea elections. The City can continue to
conduct its election in April of even years or change the election to November and consolidate
with the General Election.
ANTICIPATED COSTS
November consolidated election – County
estimate
$12-$17,000*
Traditional April election –County estimate $50,679
Traditional April election – Martin &
Chapman estimate $23,000
* The City was charged $16,340 by the County for the election in November 2009.
SUMMARY
Contracting with the Monterey County Registrar’s office for election services for an April
election is no longer a viable alternative. Staff requests Council direction to continue contracting
with Martin & Chapman for its April election or to take measures to move the election to
November and consolidate with the County and other agencies.
CITY COUNCIL: Report & Policy Guidance on Modification to Devendorf Park
Meeting Date: October 5, 2010
Prepared by: Mike Branson
City Council
Agenda Item Summary
Name: Receive report and provide policy guidance on modifications to Devendorf Park.
Description: During its regular meeting of 4 February 2010, the Forest and Beach Commission
reviewed a proposal presented by Carmel resident Barbara Livingston to open up the
Mission Street side of the park and to remove the camellia shrubs growing beneath the
large signature oak tree near the corner of Ocean Ave. and Mission St. Her full proposal
is included as Attachment 1.
Overall Cost:
City Funds: Unknown.
Grant Funds: Not applicable.
Staff Recommendation: Provide policy direction regarding the proposed modifications to
Devendorf Park.
Important Considerations: The Forest and Beach Commission reviewed the proposal on 4 February
2010 and made three recommendations: 1) to substantially cut back the camellias to
accent the heritage oak; 2) look into the possibility of a new “Y” entrance from Mission
Street; and 3) leave the hedge on Mission Street as a barrier between the Park and the
street.
Decision Record: The Forest and Beach Commission reviewed the current proposal on 4 February
2010 and a similar proposal on 7 November 2002.
Reviewed by:
______________________________ _________________
Rich Guillen, City Administrator Date
CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
STAFF REPORT
TO: MAYOR McCLOUD AND COUNCIL MEMBERS
THRU: RICH GUILLEN, CITY ADMINISTRATOR
FROM: MIKE BRANSON, CITY FORESTER
DATE: 23 SEPTEMBER 2010
SUBJECT: REVIEW AND PROVIDE POLICY GUIDANCE ON
MODIFICATIONS TO DEVENDORF PARK
RECOMMENDED ACTION
Provide policy direction regarding the proposed modifications to Devendorf Park.
BACKGROUND
Carmel resident Barbara Livingston presented a proposal to the City to modify Devendorf
Park to open up the Park to Mission Street that would remove the camellia shrubs growing
beneath the large coast live oak tree near the corner of Mission Street and Ocean Avenue.
REVIEW
The Forest and Beach Commission reviewed the proposal on 4 February 2010. After
discussion and public input, the Commission recommended: 1) substantially cutting back the
camellias to accent the heritage oak; 2) looking into the possibility of a new “Y” entrance
from Mission Street; and 3) leaving the hedge on Mission Street as a barrier between the
Park and the street. A similar proposal was discussed by the Forest and Beach Commission
in 2002, but no recommendations were given or action was taken.
FISCAL IMPACT
Costs associated with the proposed changes will depend on the level of implantation. Minor
items could be performed in-house, but a new pathway and/or large-scale plant removal may
be contracted out.
SUMMARY
The proposal to modify Devendorf Park was reviewed and discussed by the Forest and Beach
Commission. The Commission made the three recommendations outlined above.
Council has four options to consider:
1. Leave as is – status quo.
2. Implement the proposal as outlined in Barbara Livingston’s message.
3. Modify implementation per the Forest and Beach Commission recommendations.
4. Decide on another level of implementation.
85
Attachment #1
Devendorf Park Improvements
Barbara Livingston
August 24, 2009
TO: Mayor, Council Members and City Administrator
To make Devendorf Park more user friendly, more accessible to visitors and
residents, especially during the major CBTS festivals which are staged on Mission
Street between Ocean and 6th and include events in the Park:
Create a wide (50 feet minimum) entry on west side (Mission Street side) of park.
Remove fence (save for use elsewhere in park). Remove shrubbery, spread chips
as a connecting path to the lawn area. (Ideally, remove entire hedge and rail
fencing.)
Do not change the north or east sides of park.
The view into the park at the corner of Ocean and Mission, is totally obscured by a
forbiddingly dense dark grove of camellia bushes with potential for public
nuisance and safety issues. Cut these camellias to the ground under and around
the heritage oak and spread chips to cover the ground. This will create a friendly
open entry at this important corner where people like to congregate. Install the
saved rail fencing around the tree to keep people from trampling the surface roots
of the heritage oak.
Use ROP and Middle School Habitat kids under the supervision of Craig
Hohenberger and Greg D’Ambrosio to do this work as they did for city-school
projects at Forest Hills Park, Mission Trails Nature Preserve and elsewhere. We
have a track record of those good work products. Cost for the project can be billed
against the school grant funds from the city, but surely cutting shrubbery to the
ground and removing fencing can not cost a lot of money.
Note: The idea for opening up the west side of the park came from Fred Kent,
noted urban landscape designer (Project for Public Spaces) who visited Carmelby-
the-Sea years ago and toured our parks and open spaces with City
Administrator Jere Kersnar and Planning Commissioner Pope Coleman. These
ideas were taken to the F & B Commission but stalled at that level.
Additionally the city could tap into the natural spring under the park branch library
parking lot. Install underground storage tank (like at Del Mar) for irrigating
Devendorf. This will be especially helpful should water for gardens be severely
curtailed or totally eliminated.
Prepared by: Mike Branson
City Council
Agenda Item Summary
Name: Receive report and provide policy guidance on modifications to Devendorf Park.
Description: During its regular meeting of 4 February 2010, the Forest and Beach Commission
reviewed a proposal presented by Carmel resident Barbara Livingston to open up the
Mission Street side of the park and to remove the camellia shrubs growing beneath the
large signature oak tree near the corner of Ocean Ave. and Mission St. Her full proposal
is included as Attachment 1.
Overall Cost:
City Funds: Unknown.
Grant Funds: Not applicable.
Staff Recommendation: Provide policy direction regarding the proposed modifications to
Devendorf Park.
Important Considerations: The Forest and Beach Commission reviewed the proposal on 4 February
2010 and made three recommendations: 1) to substantially cut back the camellias to
accent the heritage oak; 2) look into the possibility of a new “Y” entrance from Mission
Street; and 3) leave the hedge on Mission Street as a barrier between the Park and the
street.
Decision Record: The Forest and Beach Commission reviewed the current proposal on 4 February
2010 and a similar proposal on 7 November 2002.
Reviewed by:
______________________________ _________________
Rich Guillen, City Administrator Date
CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
STAFF REPORT
TO: MAYOR McCLOUD AND COUNCIL MEMBERS
THRU: RICH GUILLEN, CITY ADMINISTRATOR
FROM: MIKE BRANSON, CITY FORESTER
DATE: 23 SEPTEMBER 2010
SUBJECT: REVIEW AND PROVIDE POLICY GUIDANCE ON
MODIFICATIONS TO DEVENDORF PARK
RECOMMENDED ACTION
Provide policy direction regarding the proposed modifications to Devendorf Park.
BACKGROUND
Carmel resident Barbara Livingston presented a proposal to the City to modify Devendorf
Park to open up the Park to Mission Street that would remove the camellia shrubs growing
beneath the large coast live oak tree near the corner of Mission Street and Ocean Avenue.
REVIEW
The Forest and Beach Commission reviewed the proposal on 4 February 2010. After
discussion and public input, the Commission recommended: 1) substantially cutting back the
camellias to accent the heritage oak; 2) looking into the possibility of a new “Y” entrance
from Mission Street; and 3) leaving the hedge on Mission Street as a barrier between the
Park and the street. A similar proposal was discussed by the Forest and Beach Commission
in 2002, but no recommendations were given or action was taken.
FISCAL IMPACT
Costs associated with the proposed changes will depend on the level of implantation. Minor
items could be performed in-house, but a new pathway and/or large-scale plant removal may
be contracted out.
SUMMARY
The proposal to modify Devendorf Park was reviewed and discussed by the Forest and Beach
Commission. The Commission made the three recommendations outlined above.
Council has four options to consider:
1. Leave as is – status quo.
2. Implement the proposal as outlined in Barbara Livingston’s message.
3. Modify implementation per the Forest and Beach Commission recommendations.
4. Decide on another level of implementation.
85
Attachment #1
Devendorf Park Improvements
Barbara Livingston
August 24, 2009
TO: Mayor, Council Members and City Administrator
To make Devendorf Park more user friendly, more accessible to visitors and
residents, especially during the major CBTS festivals which are staged on Mission
Street between Ocean and 6th and include events in the Park:
Create a wide (50 feet minimum) entry on west side (Mission Street side) of park.
Remove fence (save for use elsewhere in park). Remove shrubbery, spread chips
as a connecting path to the lawn area. (Ideally, remove entire hedge and rail
fencing.)
Do not change the north or east sides of park.
The view into the park at the corner of Ocean and Mission, is totally obscured by a
forbiddingly dense dark grove of camellia bushes with potential for public
nuisance and safety issues. Cut these camellias to the ground under and around
the heritage oak and spread chips to cover the ground. This will create a friendly
open entry at this important corner where people like to congregate. Install the
saved rail fencing around the tree to keep people from trampling the surface roots
of the heritage oak.
Use ROP and Middle School Habitat kids under the supervision of Craig
Hohenberger and Greg D’Ambrosio to do this work as they did for city-school
projects at Forest Hills Park, Mission Trails Nature Preserve and elsewhere. We
have a track record of those good work products. Cost for the project can be billed
against the school grant funds from the city, but surely cutting shrubbery to the
ground and removing fencing can not cost a lot of money.
Note: The idea for opening up the west side of the park came from Fred Kent,
noted urban landscape designer (Project for Public Spaces) who visited Carmelby-
the-Sea years ago and toured our parks and open spaces with City
Administrator Jere Kersnar and Planning Commissioner Pope Coleman. These
ideas were taken to the F & B Commission but stalled at that level.
Additionally the city could tap into the natural spring under the park branch library
parking lot. Install underground storage tank (like at Del Mar) for irrigating
Devendorf. This will be especially helpful should water for gardens be severely
curtailed or totally eliminated.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Labels
- 2014/15 Monterey County Civil Grand Jury (2)
- 2015-2023 Housing Element (1)
- Active Code Compliance (5)
- Agenda Bill (128)
- Agenda Forecast (14)
- Agenda Item Summary (686)
- Agreement (24)
- Amendments (22)
- Announcements (1)
- Appeal (45)
- Appointments (4)
- Attachment (10)
- Ballot Measure (1)
- Boards and Commissions (2)
- Budget (5)
- Budget Report (1)
- California Public Records Act (6)
- CalPERS (6)
- CalRecycle (1)
- Capital Improvement Plan (14)
- Carmel Beach Fires (11)
- Carmel Beach Restrooms Project (2)
- Carmel CalPERS Pension Committee Report (1)
- Carmel Chamber of Commerce (3)
- Carmel Fire Ambulance Association (1)
- Carmel Police Department (21)
- Carmel Public Library Foundation (10)
- Carmel Restaurant Improvement District (3)
- Centennial (11)
- Check Register (130)
- Circulation Element (1)
- City Administrator (58)
- City Attorney (26)
- City Budget (20)
- City Council Agenda and Minutes (294)
- City Council Goals (3)
- City Council Members (19)
- City Council Review (1)
- City Objectives and Key Initiatives (2)
- City of Monterey Fire Department (15)
- Claim (1)
- Closed Session (43)
- Coastal Access and Recreation Element (1)
- Coastal Development Permit (2)
- Coastal Resource Management Element (1)
- Code Compliance Report (2)
- Commercial Design Guidelines (1)
- Community Activities and Cultural Commission (12)
- Community Activities and Cultural Commission Agendas and Minutes (66)
- Community Planning and Building Department (16)
- Conflict of Interest Code (2)
- Consultant Services Agreement (6)
- Contract (9)
- Contracts (6)
- Council Report (277)
- Design Guidelines (4)
- Design Review Board (2)
- Design Review Board Agenda and Minutes (20)
- Documents (4)
- Downtown Parking Analysis Walker Parking Consultants (4)
- Emergency Operations (1)
- Encroachment Permit (3)
- Environmental Safety Element (1)
- Exhibit "A" (9)
- Exhibit A (2)
- Facilities Use Plan (2)
- Fair Political Practices Commission (1)
- Farmers' Market (1)
- fi (1)
- Financial Report (3)
- Financial Statement Audit (5)
- Findings (3)
- Fiscal Year 2013-2014 Operating Plan and Budget (2)
- Fiscal Year 2014-2015 Operating Plan and Budget (1)
- Fiscal Year 2015-2016 Operating Plan and Budget (3)
- Fiscal Year 2016-2017 Operating Plan and Budget (3)
- Fiscal Year 2017-2018 Operating Plan and Budget (7)
- Fiscal Year 2018-2019 Operating Plan and Budget (3)
- Five-Year Financial Forecast (2)
- Flanders Mansion (3)
- Flanders Mansion Property (15)
- Flanders Mansion Property Resolution (18)
- Forest and Beach Commission (14)
- Forest and Beach Commission Agendas and Minutes (68)
- Forest Management Plan (FMP) (2)
- Forest Theater Foundation (1)
- Forest Theater Guild (1)
- Forest Theater Use Agreement (2)
- Forest Theatre (20)
- Forest Theatre Design (4)
- Forester Reports (1)
- Fort Ord Reuse Authority (FORA) (1)
- General Municipal Election (7)
- General Plan (1)
- General Plan and Local Coastal Plan (10)
- Government (1)
- Green Building Program (4)
- Green Waste Recovery (7)
- Harassment Prevention Policy (3)
- Harrison Memorial Library and Park Branch Library (1)
- Harrison Memorial Library Board of Trustees (8)
- Harrison Memorial Library Board of Trustees Agendas and Minutes (72)
- Historic Context Statement (2)
- Historic Preservation (2)
- Historic Resources Board (9)
- Historic Resources Board Agendas and Minutes (67)
- Homecrafters' Marketplace (2)
- Hospitality Improvement District (HID) (7)
- Housing Element (1)
- Inc. (1)
- Institute for Local Government (1)
- Introduction (1)
- Investigative Report on City Contracts (1)
- Joint Powers Agreement (1)
- Land Use and Community Character Element (1)
- League of California Cities (5)
- Local Coastal Plan (1)
- Mail Delivery Service (1)
- Master Fee Schedule (1)
- Mayor Dave Potter (2018-2020) (4)
- Mayor Jason Burnett (2014-2016) (14)
- Mayor Steve Dallas (2016-2018) (40)
- Memorandum of Agreement (1)
- Memorandum of Understanding (12)
- Miller Jane Kingsley v. City of Carmel-by-the-Sea et al. (2)
- Mills Act Contract (6)
- Monterey County Superior Court (2)
- Monterey County Tourism Improvement District (1)
- Monterey Peninsula Regional Water Authority (MPRWA) (1)
- Monterey Peninsula Water Management District (1)
- Monterey-Salinas Transit Board (1)
- Monthly Reports (48)
- Municipal Code (30)
- National Parking and Valet (1)
- Negative Declaration (2)
- Noise Element (1)
- Open Space and Conservation Element (1)
- Ordinance (106)
- Pacific Gas & Electric Co. (1)
- Paramedic Service Provider Agreement (1)
- Pavement Management Program Nichols Consulting Engineers (4)
- Planning Commission (39)
- Planning Commission Agendas and Minutes (85)
- Police and Fire Reports (4)
- Policy Direction (14)
- Proclamation (8)
- Professional Services Agreements (35)
- Public Facilities and Services Element (1)
- Public Records Act Log (9)
- Public Records and Media Request Log (20)
- Public Works Report and Infrastructure Report Card (1)
- Public Workshop (34)
- Quarterly Financial Report (7)
- Request for Proposals (RFP) (2)
- Residential Design Guidelines (2)
- Resolution (599)
- RFEIF for Sale of the Flanders Mansion Property (1)
- RFEIR for Sale of the Flanders Mansion Property (3)
- Salary Schedule (3)
- Scout House (2)
- Separate Cover (42)
- Settlement Agreement (1)
- Shoreline Management Plan (SMP) (2)
- Special City Council Meeting (9)
- Special City Council Meeting Agenda (18)
- Special Event Permit (1)
- Staff Report (619)
- State of the Forest (1)
- Strategic Plan Vision Guiding Values (1)
- Sunset Center Master Plan (1)
- Sunset Cultural Center (23)
- Town Hall Meeting (1)
- Transportation Authority of Monterey County (TAMC) (1)
- Treasure's Report (2)
- Triennial Budget (3)
- Unfunded Accrued Liability (UAL) (1)
- Vista Lobos Community Room (1)
- Warrants (4)
- Welcome to the Blog (1)
- Whistleblower Policy (2)
- Work Study Session (1)
- Workshop (1)
- World War I Memorial Arch (2)
- Zoning Map (1)
Blog Archive
-
►
2018
(216)
- November (27)
- September (35)
- August (24)
- June (36)
- April (16)
- March (34)
- February (29)
- January (15)
-
►
2017
(210)
- December (22)
- November (12)
- September (32)
- August (17)
- July (25)
- June (24)
- May (2)
- April (24)
- March (40)
- February (12)
-
►
2016
(220)
- December (36)
- November (1)
- October (50)
- July (32)
- June (23)
- May (1)
- April (32)
- March (1)
- February (17)
- January (27)
-
►
2015
(253)
- December (2)
- November (25)
- October (44)
- August (48)
- July (19)
- June (7)
- May (31)
- April (20)
- February (19)
- January (38)
-
►
2014
(250)
- November (27)
- October (27)
- September (21)
- August (18)
- June (22)
- May (40)
- March (40)
- February (27)
- January (28)
-
►
2013
(258)
- November (46)
- October (16)
- September (27)
- August (30)
- June (45)
- May (22)
- April (24)
- March (13)
- February (15)
- January (20)
-
►
2012
(264)
- December (19)
- November (18)
- October (25)
- September (22)
- August (20)
- July (26)
- June (19)
- May (10)
- April (42)
- March (22)
- February (21)
- January (20)
-
►
2011
(224)
- December (15)
- October (40)
- September (20)
- July (35)
- June (20)
- May (18)
- April (27)
- February (35)
- January (14)
-
►
2010
(249)
- December (18)
- November (19)
- October (20)
- September (26)
- August (34)
- July (18)
- June (25)
- May (14)
- April (21)
- February (36)
- January (18)